Quality of Life and Depression among Postmenopausal Women in Pakistan
Madeeha Malik1*, Mahjabeen Mahjabeen1, Shazana Rana2, Azhar Hussain3, Ayisha Hashmi1
1Hamdard Institute of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Hamdard University Islamabad, Pakistan. 2HITEC-IMS Taxila Cantt, Pakistan. 3Faculty of Pharmacy, Hamdard University Islamabad, Pakistan.
Abstract
The reduced quality of life and increased depression among menopausal women places an increased disease burden on the healthcare system in developing nations such as Pakistan. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the menopausal-specific quality of life and depression among postmenopausal women in Pakistan. A descriptive cross-sectional study design was used. Respondents of the research included postmenopausal women visiting gynecologic clinics of healthcare equipment and facilities located in Pakistan’s twin cities. The sample size was calculated to be 382 patients to achieve a 95% confidence level with a 5% margin of error. Two pre-validated structured questionnaires were used for the collection of data in this study, i.e. Menopause Specific Quality of Life (MENQOL) and Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS). Mann-Whitney and Kruskal-Wallis (p ≥ 0.05) tests were applied according to different demographic variables.
The results indicated that there was a significant difference (p ≤0.05) between different levels of education and the presence of depressive symptoms among postmenopausal women. A significant difference (p<0.05) was seen among respondents having a different number of children. Respondents having no children were comparatively more bothered in the psychosocial and physical domain than other respondents. The results obtained from this study indicated poor quality of life and moderate depression among post-menopausal women in Pakistan. The stigma and fear associated with menopause should be reduced by providing counseling to women regarding the effects of menopause on the body and the importance of adopting a physical and healthy lifestyle by healthcare professionals.
Keywords: Postmenopause, Women, Quality of life, Depression, Pakistan
INRODUCTION
Menopause is a transition that women undergo in the mid-stages of life which involves the slow process of menstrual cycle cessation, which in turn, triggers various physiological changes in the body such as vascular instability, atrophy of the urogenital tract, bone and skin diseases as well as soft tissue disorders [1, 2]. The menopausal phase also includes other common symptoms like hot flashes, night sweats, a myriad of nonspecific emotional and psychological distresses, decreased sexual functioning and libido [3]. The menopausal common key symptoms can be categorized in four areas depending on nature, i.e. psychosocial, physical, vasomotor, and sexual [4]. In the menopausal phase, women have higher levels of depression and anxiety, hormonal changes are linked with increased mood swings, which have been strongly associated with the deprivation of estrogens in females after menopause [5]. The quality of life (QoL) of women is highly influenced during menopause as it is a major biological change in one’s life, and can produce physical as well as emotional changes in females [6].
Along with physiological changes, women during the post-menopausal phase have a greater risk of developing depression, anxiety, and other cardiovascular diseases therefore adoption of a healthy lifestyle and proper management of co-morbidities among post-menopausal women is of prime importance. The changes associated with menopausal women are highly linked with the development of other non-communicable diseases, e.g. hypertension, diabetes, breast and cervical cancer, and osteoporosis [7]. Several physiological and social evolutions happening during female mid-life may intensify the risk of depressive disorders. These changes increase the incidence of menopausal complaints, which result in higher rates of depression among females. Depressive condition and mood have a negative effect that impairs the quality of life, sleep, sexual function, resilience, and life satisfaction of mid-aged women. Depression is also related to a higher risk of increased body weight, cardio-vascular diseases, poor cognitive function, subclinical inflammation, and osteoporosis [8].
Women in developing countries such as Pakistan lack basic knowledge about the physiology of menopause and its signs and symptoms and they tend to avoid discussion about it or seek medical help. This behavior may result in reduced QoL as well as enhanced chances of developing depression among postmenopausal women in Pakistan. To design effective interventions aimed at improving quality of life, it is necessary to assess the current status as well as factors affecting the quality of life in postmenopausal women. Therefore, this research was done to evaluate the QoL and depression among postmenopausal women in Pakistan.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
In order to assess menopausal quality of life and depression among post-menopausal women in Pakistan, a descriptive cross-sectional study design was applied. Study approval was taken from the Ethical Committee of Hamdard University (BASR-78-5). Approval was also taken from medical superintendents of different hospitals of Islamabad and Rawalpindi. Respondents were briefed regarding the nature and objectives of the study. Verbal and written consent were obtained before data collection from respondents. Respondents were assured of the confidentiality of their responses and their right to withdraw from the study whenever they wanted. The study respondents were postmenopausal women aged between 40-65 years old. Patients were categorized based on age between 40-65 years old, whose last menstrual period occurred within a period of last 1-5 years, and had normal menopause. Raosoft sample size calculator was used for calculation of the sample size at 95% confidence interval and 5% margin of error which came to be 382. Convenient sampling techniques were used and all the respondents available upon data collection were chosen. Two pre-validated structured questionnaires were used for the collection of data in this study i.e. Menopause Specific Quality of Life (MENQOL) and Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) to evaluate menopause specific quality of life and depression respectively among postmenopausal women from twin cities of Pakistan.
Menopause specific Quality of Life developed by Hilditch J R [9] includes 5 domains such as vasomotor (hot flushes, night sweats, and sweating), psychological (anxiousness, poor memory, lowered ability, feeling depressed, impatient, wanting to be alone), physical (flatulence, muscles and joints pain, tiredness, difficulty sleeping, backaches, decreased stamina, lack of energy, dry skin, weight gain, weakness, increased facial hair, change in skin texture, bloating, low backache, frequent and/or involuntary urination) sexual (changes in sexual desire, vaginal dryness and avoiding intimacy) and others (palpitation, headache, dizziness). The Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) measures the extent to which patients experience anxiety or depressive symptoms. It consists of 7 items each for anxiety and depression [10].
Pilot testing was performed on 10% of the sample size to check the reliability of the tool. The value of Cronbach's alpha was 0.70 for MENQOL and 0.69 for HADS. Data nwas cleaned, coded, and analyzed using SPSS 21. Descriptive statistics comprised of frequencies and percentages were determined. Mann-Whitney and Kruskal Wallis test (p≦0.05) was applied to determine differences among various variables.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Demographic Characteristics of Respondents
Out of 382 respondents, 30.4 % (n=116) were 40-49 years old, 43.2% (n=165) were 50-59 years old and 26.2% (n=100) were 60-65 years old. Of all the respondents, 88.5% (n=388) had menopause between the age of 44-53 years. Most of the females were married (85.6%, n=327) and over three-quarters of respondents (75.4%, n=228) had more than 3 children. A detailed description is given in Table 1.
Table 1. Demographic Characteristics of Respondents |
||
n (%) |
||
Age |
40-49 Y |
116 (30.4) |
50-59 Y |
165 (43.2) |
|
60-65 Y |
100 (26.2) |
|
Hospital |
Public |
362 (94.8) |
Private |
20 (5.2) |
|
Age at Menarche |
≤10 years |
3 (0.8) |
11-12 years |
80 (20.9) |
|
13-14 years |
213 (55.7) |
|
≥15 years |
86 (22.5) |
|
Age at Menopause |
≤40 years |
8 (2.1) |
41-45 years |
72 (14.3) |
|
46-50 years |
164 (42.9) |
|
>50years |
137 (35.8) |
|
Marital Status |
Married |
327 (85.6) |
Unmarried |
14 (3.7) |
|
Divorced |
39 (10.2) |
|
Qualification |
Illiterate |
108 (28.3) |
Primary |
44 (11.5) |
|
Secondary |
85 (22.3) |
|
Bachelor |
78 (20.4) |
|
Masters |
56 (14.7) |
|
Post Graduate |
11 (2.9) |
|
No of Children |
None |
34 (8.9) |
1 |
15 (3.9) |
|
2 |
45 (11.8) |
|
3 |
96 (25.1) |
|
4 |
97 (25.4) |
|
More than Four |
95 (24.9) |
|
Setting |
Urban |
238 (62.3) |
Rural |
144 (37.7) |
|
Work Status |
Employed |
150 (39.3) |
Housewife |
229 (59.9) |
|
Type of Morbidity |
None |
164 (42.9) |
Hypertension |
116 (30.4) |
|
Diabetes |
40 (10.5) |
|
Others |
62 (16.2) |
|
Type of Therapy |
Hormone Replacement Therapy |
19 (5.0) |
Others |
360 (94.2) |
Mean Scores of Menopause Specific Quality of Life among Postmenopausal Women
The results obtained from this study highlighted that mean scores for the sexual domain were higher (4.52, ±4.05) indicating the poor menopause-specific quality of life in this domain whereas the lowest scores were seen for the psychosocial domain (3.29, ±3.92). A detailed description is shown in Table 2.
Table 2. Mean Scores of Menopause Specific Quality of Life among Postmenopausal Women |
|||
Vasomotor |
Psychosocial |
Physical |
Sexual |
Mean ± SD |
Mean ± SD |
Mean ± SD |
Mean ± SD |
3.83 (±4.05) |
3.29 (±3.92) |
3.51 (±3.34) |
4.52 (±4.05) |
Comparison of Mean Scores of Menopause Specific Quality of Life by Demographic Variables
A significant difference (p<0.05) was observed in specific menopause quality of life among different age groups. Respondents having age greater than 60 years were more bothered concerning vasomotor, psychosocial, physical, and sexual domains of menopause quality of life as compared to other age groups. A significant difference was observed (p<0.05) among different levels of education. Illiterate respondents were comparatively more worrisome in the physical domain whereas the sexual domain was comparatively more disturbed among postgraduate respondents. A significant difference (p<0.05) was seen among respondents having a different number of children. Respondents having no children were comparatively more bothered in the psychosocial and physical domain than other respondents. A significant difference (p<0.05) was seen among respondents having different types of co-morbidities. Respondents having hypertension and diabetes were comparatively more bothered in the psychosocial domain than other respondents whereas respondents having diabetes were more bothered in the sexual domain. No significant difference was observed among respondents having different marital statuses and using different types of therapies. A detailed description is given in Table 3.
Table 3. Comparison of Mean Scores of Menopause Specific Quality of Life by Demographic Variables |
||||||||||||||||
Variables |
Vasomotor |
Psychosocial |
Physical |
Sexual |
||||||||||||
n |
Mean Rank |
Test Statistics |
p-value |
n |
Mean Rank |
Test Statistics |
p-value |
n |
Mean Rank |
Test Statistics |
p-value |
n |
Mean Rank |
Test Statistics |
p-value |
|
Age |
40-49=116 |
161.33 |
14.633b |
0.002 |
40-49=116 |
161.41 |
17.484b |
0.001 |
40-49=116 |
143.99 |
43.899b |
0.001 |
40-49=116 |
151.45 |
33.852b |
0.001 |
50-59= 165 |
202.72 |
50-59= 165 |
193.51 |
50-59= 165 |
195.07 |
50-59= 165 |
191.45 |
|||||||||
60-65=99 |
209.39 |
60-65=99 |
222.28 |
60-65=99 |
241.99 |
60-65=99 |
236.55 |
|||||||||
Marital Status |
Unmarried= 14 |
195.74 |
3.588b |
0.309 |
Unmarried= 14 |
186.04 |
4.636b |
0.200 |
Unmarried= 14 |
186.95 |
5.548b |
0.136 |
Unmarried= 14 |
188.24 |
6.326b |
0.097 |
Married= 327 |
155.46 |
Married= 327 |
214.57 |
|
Married= 327 |
247.54 |
Married= 327 |
214.68 |
||||||||
Divorced=39 |
170.82 |
Divorced=39 |
222.15 |
|
Divorced=39 |
211.09 |
Divorced=39 |
217.65 |
||||||||
Level of Education |
Illiterate= 108 |
186.01 |
4.199b |
0.521 |
Illiterate= 108 |
205.69 |
14.850b |
0.011 |
Illiterate= 108 |
214.49 |
25.298b |
0.001 |
Illiterate= 108 |
255.71 |
60.138b |
0.001 |
Primary= 44 |
199.57 |
Primary= 44 |
196.39 |
Primary= 44 |
214.49 |
Primary= 44 |
186.00 |
|||||||||
Secondary= 85 |
210.09 |
Secondary= 85 |
210.39 |
Secondary= 85 |
211.39 |
Secondary= 85 |
147.44 |
|||||||||
Bachelors= 78 |
186.26 |
Bachelors= 78 |
163.44 |
Bachelors= 78 |
153.67 |
Bachelors= 78 |
168.21 |
|||||||||
Masters= 56 |
176.43 |
Masters= 56 |
160.85 |
Masters= 56 |
163.05 |
Masters= 56 |
187.62 |
|||||||||
Post Graduate= 11 |
183.32 |
Post Graduate= 11 |
226.09 |
Post Graduate= 11 |
133.18 |
Post Graduate= 11 |
108.41 |
|||||||||
Number of Children |
None= 34 |
171.74 |
9.305b |
0.097 |
None= 34 |
236.37 |
15.444b |
0.009 |
None= 34 |
235.22 |
17.773b |
0.003 |
None= 34 |
209.72 |
6.610b |
0.251 |
1= 15 |
180.97 |
1= 15 |
228.10 |
1= 15 |
211.20 |
1= 15 |
218.67 |
|||||||||
2= 45 |
166.22 |
2= 45 |
177.36 |
2= 45 |
158.59 |
2= 45 |
170.21 |
|||||||||
3= 96 |
179.69 |
3= 96 |
176.26 |
3= 96 |
169.39 |
3= 96 |
180.20 |
|||||||||
4= 97 |
202.08 |
4= 97 |
171.98 |
4= 97 |
188.06 |
4= 97 |
186.71 |
|||||||||
More than 4= 95 |
213.34 |
More than 4= 95 |
209.49 |
More than 4= 95 |
214.19 |
More than 4= 95 |
207.08 |
|||||||||
Type of Co-morbidity |
None= 164 |
184.88 |
7.223b |
0.065 |
None= 164 |
180.59 |
10.381b |
0.016 |
None= 164 |
181.55 |
5.957b |
0.114 |
None= 164 |
197.32 |
13.883b |
0.003 |
Hypertension= 116 |
183.56 |
Hypertension= 116 |
211.96 |
Hypertension= 116 |
206.49 |
Hypertension= 116 |
195.14 |
|||||||||
Diabetes= 40 |
188.45 |
Diabetes= 40 |
211.88 |
Diabetes= 40 |
211.86 |
Diabetes= 40 |
224.63 |
|||||||||
Others= 62 |
225.82 |
Others= 62 |
165.69 |
Others= 62 |
176.63 |
Others= 62 |
147.93 |
|||||||||
Type of Therapy |
Hormone replacement therapy= 19 |
229.37 |
2672.000a |
0.108 |
Hormone replacement therapy= 19 |
221.79 |
2797.000a |
0.186 |
Hormone replacement therapy= 19 |
221.79 |
3010.000a |
0.378 |
Hormone replacement therapy= 19 |
221.79 |
3336.000a |
0.857 |
Others= 360 |
187.92 |
Others= 360 |
187.79 |
Others= 360 |
187.79 |
Others= 360 |
187.79 |
a Mann-Whitney, b Kruskal-Wallis
Comparison of Hospital Anxiety and Depression among Postmenopausal Women according to Different Demographic Variables
A significant difference (p ≤0.05) was seen between different levels of education and the presence of depressive symptoms among postmenopausal women. Illiterate respondents had a comparatively higher level of depressive symptoms than those with masters and postgraduate education. On the contrary, no significant difference (p≧0.05) was seen for depression among respondents belonging to different age groups, having different marital status and number of children. Likewise, no significant difference was seen (p≧0.05) in depression scores among respondents who had any co-morbidity and received different types of therapies. A detailed description is given in Table 4.
Table 4. The Comparison of Hospital Anxiety and Depression among Postmenopausal Women according to Different Demographic Variables |
||||
Demographics |
n |
Mean Rank |
Test Statistics |
p-value |
Age |
40-49=116 |
131.39 |
4.164b |
0.125 |
50-59= 165 |
139.91 |
|||
60-65=99 |
122.19 |
|||
Marital Status |
Unmarried= 14 Married= 327 Divorced=39 |
29.96 25.94 22.15 |
231.500a |
0.400 |
Level of Education |
Illiterate= 108 |
168.12 |
27.76b |
0.001 |
Primary= 44 |
112.76 |
|||
Secondary= 85 |
151.08 |
|||
Bachelors= 78 |
162.65 |
|||
Masters= 56 |
109.83 |
|||
Post Graduate= 11 |
76.45 |
|||
Number of Children |
None= 34 |
165.25 |
7.242b
|
0.124
|
1= 15 |
205.68 |
|||
2= 45 |
158.91 |
|||
3= 96 |
163.21 |
|||
4= 97 |
192.72 |
|||
More than 4= 95 |
168.27 |
|||
Type of Co-morbidity |
None= 164 |
143.24 |
3056.000a |
0.136 |
Hypertension= 116 |
104.00 |
|||
Diabetes= 40 |
106.98 |
|||
Others= 62 |
119.83 |
|||
Type of Therapy |
Hormone replacement therapy= 19 |
181.47 |
1.130a |
0.288 |
Others= 360 |
246.00 |
Mann-Whitney Test (p ≥0.05)a Krsukal Wallis Test (p≥ 0.05b).
During the transition phase of menopause, women experience fluctuations in levels of hormones due to which women at a later age experience a variety of symptoms and syndromes. The signs of different fluctuations vary among different women. The menopausal phase is linked with physical symptoms and signs as well as emotional changes in women [11]. Reduced adherence to healthy behaviors and lifestyle changes and low levels of knowledge regarding menopause can lead to reduced QoL. The reduced QoL among menopausal women places an increased disease burden on the healthcare system in developing nations such as Pakistan [12]. The present study showed the reduced menopausal specific quality of life and depression among postmenopausal women in Pakistan.
Menopausal symptoms can hurt various aspects of QoL among women. The results obtained from this study showed that older women were more bothered in all four domains of quality of life than younger women. This might be because older women experience more debilitating symptoms due to menopause. Women who had completed secondary education had poor quality of life in the psychosocial domain whereas illiterate women had more physical problems and postgraduate women were more bothered due to poor quality of life in terms of the sexual domain. Women who had no children reported poor quality of life in psychosocial and physical domains. Diabetic as well as hypertensive women had poor psychosocial health whereas diabetic women were also bothered in the sexual domain. Identical findings were observed in a study carried out in Saudi Arabia where menopausal women having old age, no children, no formal education, and suffering from co-morbidities had a poor menopausal specific QoL [13].
The most prevalent symptoms associated with menopause are categorized into four different areas like physiological, physical, vasomotor, and sexual along with these post-menopausal women are at higher risk of cardiovascular disease, anxiety, and depression. The results of the present study revealed that postmenopausal women experienced moderate to severe depression that varies in its severity, as severity is greater at the start of menopause and gradually lowered down to moderate depression in women of older age. This might be due to the physical and hormonal changes which the patient is experiencing. Identical findings were reported from a study conducted in China which reported that management of depression and anxiety associated with post-menopausal women is necessary to improve quality of life [14].
CONCLUSION
The results of this research revealed poor quality of life and moderate depression among post-menopausal women in Pakistan. The quality of life was lowest in the domain of sexual and vasomotor functioning while was moderately better in the domain of psychosocial functioning. The stigma and fear associated with menopause should be reduced by providing counseling to women regarding the effects of menopause on the body and the importance of adopting a physical and healthy lifestyle by healthcare professionals. Post-menopausal clinics should be developed to promote healthy living and to reduce anxiety and depression under the supervision of a psychologist.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS: We acknowledge the support of Medical Superintendents of all healthcare facilities for allowing data collection.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST: None
FINANCIAL SUPPORT: Nil
ETHICS STATEMENT: Ethical approval was taken from Hamdard University Ethical Committee.
LIMITATIONS: The present study was carried out in twin cities of Pakistan and the obtained results may not be generalizable to the rest of the country. Time and financial limitations were a few of the barriers faced by the principal investigator.
Copyright © 2024 Archives of Pharmacy Practice. Authors retain copyright of their article if they are accepted for publication.
Developed by Archives of Pharmacy Practice